Skip to content
Steven AverytranscripttranscriptJury Question About Bobby Dassey’s Testimony - Day 25 - Steven AveryThe jury asked to read or hear Bobby Dassey's testimony on Day 25, and both sides accepted the judge's proposed response.
Thomas J. FallonKenneth R. KratzDean A. StrangPatrick L. WillisBobby DasseyTHE COURTMR. KRATZMR. STRANGMR. FALLONjury_question
Steven Avery/Day 25/March 16, 2007
3 pages·1 witness·75 lines
After a juror was excused for a family emergency, the court recalled an alternate and instructed the jury to begin deliberations anew. The jury later requested Bobby Dassey’s testimony, and the court proposed inviting a more specific request rather than providing the full transcript.
Jury QuestionsJury QuestionsJury question about Bobby Dassey's testimony Bobby Dassey

(Question from the jury and the Judge's reply.)

THE COURT: At this time we are on the record, outside the presence of the jury. All counsel, except Mr. Gahn, are present, and the defendant is also present, in person.

I can indicate for the record that the Court has received a written question from the jury dated today, at 1:29 p.m. Following receipt of the question, I met with counsel in chambers and discussed a proposed answer to the question.

I believe the parties are in agreement with that answer. I will read the question and the answer at this time and then ask the parties if the answer is acceptable. The question from the jury reads: Could we please read or hear a transcript of Bobby Dassey's testimony. It is signed by Daniel Slaby, who I presume to be the foreperson, dated today at 1:29 p.m.

The proposed answer is the following: Dear Jury Members, this is in response to your request for a transcript of Bobby Dassey's testimony. As the Court has instructed you, you will not have a copy of the written transcript of the trial testimony available for use during your deliberations. You may ask to have specific portions of the testimony read to you. You must continue to rely primarily on your memory of the evidence and the testimony introduced during the trial.

The Court does not have and cannot provide you with a transcript of Bobby Dassey's entire testimony. If you can identify a specific portion of his testimony, the Court will attempt to address your request. Please do not disclose the state of your deliberations in any such request. Signed by me. Mr. Kratz, is that answer acceptable to the State?

THE COURT: Mr. Strang, Mr. Buting, I don't know if you discussed this matter with your client, I will give you an opportunity to do so if you wish.

MR. STRANG: Mr. Buting did, briefly. The answer is acceptable both to defense counsel and to Mr. Avery.

THE COURT: Very well, if there's nothing further, I will send the original copy of the answer back to the jury and then keep the jurors question and a copy of the answer for the court file.

MR. FALLON: Do you want us to wait here in case there is a quick reply?

THE COURT: Actually, I have got another matter I would like to talk to you in chambers about, so let's meet back there.

(Court in recess, jury deliberating.)

Continue to Day 261.Jury Request and Rereading of Culhane’s Rifle DNA Testimony